This ensures your brows remain soft while still shaping and filling in. Consider going for a shade or two lighter. If you have black hair, a harsh black eyebrow pencil may not be the right choice for you. It shouldn’t be more than a shade darker.Ī shade darker is a better choice. It’s a good idea to choose a pencil color close to your hair color. The right color of eyebrow pencil can make a massive difference in the final look of your eyebrows. Here are three important things to consider when choosing an eyebrow pencil: Color What should you look for when you’re trying to find the best eyebrow pencil? Not all eyebrow pencils are made equal, and not all of them are right for you. Three Things to Consider When Choosing the Best Eyebrow Pencil Guide to Buying the Best Eyebrow Pencil.Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil IT Cosmetics Brow Power Universal Brow Pencil Maybelline New York Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil NYX Professional Makeup Micro Brow Pencil Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil Three Things to Consider When Choosing the Best Eyebrow Pencil.